The Reality No One Talks About

33 million people. That’s how many Pakistanis were affected by the 2022 floods, roughly the entire population of Canada, displaced in months. If you’re reading this from Pakistan, you already know climate change isn’t a future threat. It’s here. It’s expensive. And it’s personal.

But here’s what bothers me as someone researching Pakistan’s climate policy: **we keep talking about government initiatives like they’re success stories when most haven’t delivered measurable results yet.**

Let me break down what’s actually happening versus what you’re being told.

What You’ve Probably Heard

“Pakistan is planting 10 billion trees!
“We’re going green with renewable energy!
“Protected areas are saving biodiversity!”

Sounds great, right? Here’s what they don’t tell you:

 The Ten Billion Tree Tsunami: Check the Numbers

The Promise: Plant 10 billion trees to restore forests and combat climate change.

The Reality Check:

How many have actually been planted? [Need to verify current figures – this is where academic rigor matters]
How many survived? (Tree planting ≠ forest restoration if 40% die in year one)
 Where were they planted? (Monoculture plantations vs. diverse ecosystems make a huge difference)

What this means for you:

If you live in urban Punjab or Sindh, you’re probably not seeing these trees. The project focuses on KPK and rural areas. Air quality in Lahore? Still terrible.

What you can actually do:

 Verify planting claims in your area: [Link to verification database if it exists]
 Support local urban tree initiatives that benefit your neighborhood
Demand transparency: Where’s the survival rate data?

Renewable Energy: The Target vs. Today

The Promise: Substantially increase renewable energy by 2030 to reduce fossil fuel dependence.

The Truth:

Current renewable energy in Pakistan’s energy mix: ~4% (as of 2024, mostly hydro)
Target for 2030: 60% renewable (massively ambitious)

 Reality: Without massive infrastructure investment, this is aspirational at best

Why this matters to YOU specifically:

Gen Z entering the job market:

– Green energy jobs are growing, but they require specific skills
– If you’re in engineering/tech, this is where opportunities are
– Resource: Energy Jobs: More than 300 Jobs

Millennials with families:

 Solar panel adoption for homes is increasing, but it is still expensive
 Government subsidies exist, but aren’t well-publicized
 Payback period: 5-7 years typically
Resource:Guide to Going Solar in Pakistan: Costs, Benefits & Installation

Families in flood-prone areas:

Renewable energy grids are more resilient than centralized fossil fuel plants
This directly affects your safety during climate disasters
Resource:Climate Risk and Vulnerability Assessment of Pakistan

 Protected Areas: Who Benefits?

The Promise:Expanding protected areas to save endangered species and ecosystems.

The Complicated Reality:

Some protected areas displace local communities
Community-based conservation” sounds nice, but implementation is inconsistent
 Tourism revenue from these areas doesn’t always reach local people

**Questions to ask:
– Who manages these areas?
– How are local communities compensated?
– Are indigenous knowledge systems integrated or ignored?

What you can do:

Visit Pakistan’s national parks (seriously, they’re incredible)
Support eco-tourism that directly benefits local guides
 Advocate for transparent revenue sharing

 The International Partnership Game

The U.S.-Pakistan Green Alliance Framework** and similar partnerships sound impressive. But let’s be real:

What’s actually in it for Pakistan?   

Technology transfer (sometimes)
 Funding (with strings attached)
Knowledge sharing (on their terms)

What’s in it for the U.S./other partners? 

Climate diplomacy points
Access to Pakistan’s market for green tech
Geopolitical influence

Your stake: These partnerships determine what solutions get funded. Local, community-led initiatives often lose out to big tech projects. Demand that your government prioritizes solutions that work for Pakistani contexts, not just what donors want to fund.

What Actually Works (And What Doesn’t)

WORKS:

✅ Local community-led conservation.When communities control resources, they protect them
✅ Urban tree planting in cities you actually live in. Immediate air quality benefits
✅ Rooftop solar for those who can afford it. Direct cost savings, grid independence
✅ Indigenous agricultural practices. Often more climate-resilient than industrial farming

 DOESN’T WORK (Yet):  

❌ Top-down policy without enforcement.  Laws exist; implementation doesn’t
❌ Green initiatives without economic incentives. People can’t afford to prioritize the environment over survival.
❌ Projects that ignore local knowledge.  Outsiders rarely understand local ecosystems better than people who’ve lived there for generations.

Your Action Menu (Pick What Fits Your Life)

 If You’re Low on Time: 

5 minutes: Share climate content from Pakistani researchers/activists (not just Western perspectives)
15 minutes: Calculate your household’s carbon footprint and identify ONE change
30 minutes: Join an online community organizing for climate policy accountability

If You’re Ready to Commit:

Volunteer: Local tree planting, river cleanup, environmental education
Advocate: Contact your MNA/MPA about specific policy asks
Support: Donate to Pakistani environmental organizations (not just international NGOs)
Learn: Follow Pakistani climate researchers and amplify their work

 If You Have Resources:

Invest: Solar panels, rainwater harvesting, energy-efficient appliances
Fund: Local environmental initiatives, youth climate activists
Create: Start a neighborhood sustainability initiative

 The Questions I’m Still Researching (Your Input Welcome)

As a PhD researcher, here’s what I don’t have answers to yet:

1. What’s the real success rate of the tree tsunami project?** Official data is vague. If you work in forestry or live near planting sites, I’d love to hear your observations.

2. How are climate policies affecting different regions inequitably?** Balochistan’s experience vs. Punjab’s is drastically different?

3. What role do you think youth climate movements should play vs. government-led initiatives?** Is activism enough, or do we need to work within existing systems?

Resources Worth Your Time

Data & Monitoring:
 Pakistan Climate Change Portal (if you want official stats)
 Pakistan Meteorological Department (actual weather/climate data)
 World Resources Institute Pakistan (third-party analysis)

For Deep Dives: 

Pakistan’s NDC (Nationally Determined Contributions) – the actual commitments
 National Climate Change Policy 2021 – what the government promises
 Independent research on policy implementation, what actually happens

 Final Truth Bomb

Pakistan is one of the world’s least responsible for climate change (less than 1% of global emissions) but among the most affected. That’s profoundly unjust.

But here’s what I’ve learned in my research: Waiting for government action or international help means waiting too long.

The families who survived the 2022 floods? Many were saved by local community networks, not government rescue operations.

The neighborhoods with breathable air? Often because residents organized tree planting, not because of policy.

Change happens when people who care enough decide they’re not waiting anymore.

Related Blog

Green IT in Pakistan: Building a Sustainable Digital Future